Edward Teller, the famous Hungarian-American physicist, once quoted:
“A fact is a simple statement that everyone believes. It is innocent, unless found guilty. A hypothesis is a novel suggestion that no one wants to believe. It is guilty, until found effective.”
Application of hypothesis testing is predominant in Data Science. It is imperative to simplify and deconstruct it. Like a crime-fiction story, hypothesis testing, based on data, leads us from a novel suggestion to an effective proposition.
Hypothesis originates from the Greek work hupo (under) and thesis(placing). It means an idea made from limited evidence. It is a starting point for further investigation.
The notion is simple yet powerful. We perform hypothesis testing intuitively every day. It is a 7-step process:
Let me illustrate a story to explain the concept of hypothesis Testing. Holmavik is a small town in the western part of Iceland. This little town has its uniqueness. It is known for the Museum of Witchcraft.
Even now, there are people in Westfjords who claim to be wizards. Isildur and Gandalf are such people. Isildur and Gandalf claim to be wizards. They claim to be Clairvoyant. A statistician wants to prove or disprove this claim. They play the Clairvoyant card game.
The rules of the game are as follows:
It is also determined that for a normal person, the average number of times the prediction is correct is around 6. This is the basis on which we will perform the hypothesis testing. We will statistically determine if they are wizards or not.
Different kinds of hypothesis testing make different assumptions. Assumptions are related to the distribution of data, sampling, and linearity. Some of the common assumptions made are:
For the clairvoyant card game, the following assumptions are correct:
The null hypothesis is the initial position. It is the status-quo position. It is the position that is rejected or fails to be rejected. It is the position that needs to be validated. It is the position that needs to be tested.
For the clairvoyant card game, the NULL hypothesis the following:
He is simply guessing. He is lucky.
The alternate hypothesis is the contrary position to NULL hypothesis. If there are statistically significant evidences that suggest that the alternate hypothesis is valid, then the NULL hypothesis is rejected.
For the clairvoyant card game, the alternate hypothesis is the following:
The NULL and alternate hypothesis is defined. The status-quo is the NULL hypothesis. Now, a threshold needs to be set. We know that an average individual i.e. someone who is not a wizard would get it correct six times out of 10. If Isildur and Gandalf can predict the more than six correct cards in a test, then there is more evidence that they may indeed be wizards. A metric called as t-statistics calculates how far the estimated value is from the hypothesized value. High t-statistics makes the alternate hypothesis look more and more plausible.
The hypothesis test results may go wrong. There are four possible scenarios:
The test hits the bullseye for outcomes 1 and two is correct. The test fizzles out for outcomes 3 and 4.
Like all statistical testing, hypothesis testing has to deal with uncertainty. It has to deal in probabilities. There are no absolutes.
A probability level needs to be set such that the chance of Type I error occurring is established. This level is called as the significance level. The alpha (α) denotes it. A lower α means that the test is very stringent. A relatively higher α means that the test is not so strict. The value of α is set based on the nature of the hypothesis test. Typical values are 0.001, 0.05 or 0.1
What if the value observed is by mere chance? What if it is just a coincidence? What if they are just lucky on the very day when the test was conducted? This uncertainty needs to be mitigated. Hypothesis testing has a metric that takes care of this uncertainty. p-value is that metric.
The p-value is expressed as a probability. It means that its value is between 0 and 1. The p-value is the probability that the t-statistic observed by chance under the assumption that NULL hypothesis is true.
For the clairvoyant card game, it was decided that if Isildur can guess more than 8 cards correctly then the alternative hypothesis is plausible. He may be indeed a clairvoyant. The t-statistics is 8.
Being a clairvoyant is no life threatening. No one is in danger. The significance level was set at 0.05. The α is 0.05.
The action happens. The statisticians test the clairvoyance of Isildur and Gandalf. The cards are shown. The Predictions are made. The outcomes are noted. The process is repeated ten times. A Statistical engine runs on the collected data. The result is the following:
Isildur:
-Gandalf:
A comparison between the probability (p-value) and the significance levels yields the following result:
The tests have ended. The metrics are known. Who is the real wizard?
For Isildur: The p-value is greater than the set significance level (10% > 5%). Even though, on an average, he has predicted eight cards correctly; statistically, the conclusion is the following:
For Gandalf: On an average, he has predicted nine cards correctly. The p-value is lower than the set significance level (1% < 5%).
Isildur is devastated. Gandalf is elated. However, Isildur may take solace for it is not proven that he not a clairvoyant. The NULL hypothesis is failed to be rejected. It doesn’t mean that alternate hypothesis is not true. It only means that there is not enough evidence to reject the NULL hypothesis. Status-quo prevails for Isildur.
There is no need to perform a hypothesis test to find who is the wizard among Isildur and Gandalf. We all know that Gandalf is the wizard.
The hypothesis testing is one of the cornerstone concepts in machine learning. A lot of evaluation methods use hypothesis testing to evaluate the robustness of the models. We will deep-dive further into its constructs as we journey through this series.
Comment
Thanks for the explanation Pradeep. I think these articles are very helpful to understanding Data Science concepts.
I'd like to ask about the t-statistic though. You gave the definition: "A metric called as t-statistics calculates how far the estimated value is from the hypothesized value". I understood the estimated value to be 8 and the hypothesized value to be 6. I thought this meant that the t-statistic would be 2 (8-6) in this case.
© 2020 Data Science Central ® Powered by
Badges | Report an Issue | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
Most Popular Content on DSC
To not miss this type of content in the future, subscribe to our newsletter.
Other popular resources
Archives: 2008-2014 | 2015-2016 | 2017-2019 | Book 1 | Book 2 | More
Most popular articles
You need to be a member of Data Science Central to add comments!
Join Data Science Central